Tuesday, May 30, 2023

The 2021 Carol Awards

Share This Post

Guess what’s back! The world has been pretty chaotic for some time now and unlike our fellow awards who just postponed their ceremonies, we canceled The Carol Awards entirely.

Well after another year of utter ridiculousness especially in the world of media, we thought it was only fair to bring back our favorite awards for the best of the best! Well, best of the worst. Worst of the best? Up to you how you take it. Either way, we’re highlighting premium Dramatic Satisfaction in media.

This year we’ve got six different awards to hand out: Worst Series Finale, Worst Costuming, Worst Plot Armor, Worst Reboot Idea, Worst Nepotism Casting in TV or Film, and Worst Hollywood Business Decision, as well as a bonus award detailed near the end.

Without further ado!

Worst Series Finale

  • The 100
  • Supernatural
  • Loki
  • Kim’s Convenience
  • Falcon and the Winter Solder

And the Golden Carol goes to…

Worst Series Finale Winner is Supernatural

Worst Costuming

  • Arrowverse
  • Cursed
  • Emily in Paris
  • The Spanish Princess

And the Golden Carol goes to…

Worst Costuming Winner is Emily in Paris

Worst Plot Armor

  • Lena Luthor (Supergirl)
  • June (A Handmaid’s Tale)
  • Sylvie (Loki)

And the Golden Carol goes to…

Worst Plot Armor is June from The Handmaid's Tale

Worst Reboot Idea

  • Clifford the Big Red Dog
  • Gossip Girl
  • Lost
  • Mario
  • The Powerpuff Girls
  • Sex and the City (aka And Just Like That…)

And the Golden Carol goes to…

Worst Reboot Idea Winner is The Powerpuff Girls

Worst Nepotism Casting (TV or Film)

  • Ben Platt (Dear Evan Hansen)
  • Hero Fiennes Tiffin (After Film Series)
  • Kaia Gerber (American Horror Stories)
  • Kate Siegal (Midnight Mass)

And the Golden Carol goes to…

Worst Nepotism Casting in TV or Film Winner is Ben Platt for Dear Evan Hansen

Worst Hollywood Business Decision

  • Keeping the Golden Globes Alive
  • Lack of Safety on Film Sets
  • Not Negotiating with IATSE Until the Last Minute

And the Golden Carol goes to…

Worst Hollywood Business Decision is the Lack of Safety on Filming Sets

Though in all seriousness, this has been a problem since filming was a thing and it shouldn’t take people f*cking dying for the needle to be moved a fraction in the right direction. Shame on you, Hollywood.

The Johnny Cardboard Lifetime Achievement Award

As bland and uninspired as its namesake.

This is a new award, deliberated on and decided by our editorial staff to highlight a truly special level of hell: D&D levels of awful. Without further ado, here is the winner for 2021

Johnny Cardboard Lifetime Achievement Award goes to Copaganda.

See resources on why copaganda is a problem here, here, and here. We have also resolved to be more critical in our media reviews and consumption when covering mediums that could fall into this category, as seen with our recaps of the final season of Brooklyn Nine-Nine.

Thanks for joining us in this year’s Carol Awards, your best in Dramatic Satisfaction. All the winners, please go backstage to pick up your awards… we’re sure you’re all quite proud of yourselves.

Images courtesy of Netflix, the CW, Hulu, Universal Pictures, NBC

Have strong thoughts about this piece you need to share? Or maybe there’s something else on your mind you’re wanting to talk about with fellow Fandomentals? Head on over to our Community server to join in the conversation!


  • Kori

    Kori is an entertainment writer and Managing Editor at the Fandomentals. In her spare time, she is a fragrance and watch enthusiast, lover of Eurovision, and Yanni devotee. Find her on Instagram at @fmkori

  • Seher

    Seher is the Associate Editor-in-Chief at The Fandomentals focusing on the ins and outs of TV, media representation, games, and other topics as they pique her interest. Otherwise, she's reading away for graduate school. pc: @poika_

Latest Posts

Modiphius Announces Brand New Edition Of BRIKWARS Tabletop Wargame

Tabletop board game publisher Modiphius Entertainment bears exciting news: pre-orders for the final, definitive, best-ever version of Mike Rayhawk’s BRIKWARS are open right now! Dust off those old bricks and make sure they’re primed for battle, this tabletop wargame is coming in hot!

Misfits vs. Fascism

This month we hand the reigns over to Kara...

‘Hunger’ Works Best as an Appetizer

“Eat the rich” has gone from a rallying cry...