TerrierĀ contains many firsts for Tamora Pierce. Published in 2006, it surprises the reader with the first person journal format. Previously Pierce used close third person, but this worksās for Bekaās story. It also gives the reader their first glimpse into Tortallās past. Pierce sets this book in 246 HE, almost two hundred years before her other novels. This also is her first police and crime novel. While she dabbled in crime in the Alanna books, and mentioned the Lord Provost, now she tells us how the police system in Tortall works. Or, used to work, we hope.
Spoilers for all ofĀ Terrier and for all of Pierceās other novels.Ā
So, What Happened?
TerrierĀ opens with a flashback to Georgeās youth. Eleni bailed him out of the Guard station and told him about his famous Guard, then called Dogs, ancestress. Then we jump to 244 HE in the past, where we meet Tunstall, Clary, and the Lord Provost. The Lord Provost tells how he caught a gang of Rats, because eight-year-old Beka Cooper tracked one down.
Then, we see Beka on her first day of Puppy training, where sheās assigned to work with Tunstall and Clary as her mentors. She stumbles initially, given her shyness and overconfidence. But eventually, she grows into her job. Beka also connects to a friend from her past, Tansy, whoās married to the grandson of the most corrupt landlord in Corus. A killer called the Shadow Snake killed Tansyās son Roland. Tansy gives her a strange stone that her husband claimed would change their fortunes. Beka and her Dogs discover that itās fire opals, mined by Crookshank, Tansyās grandfather-in-law.
Through her magic with ghosts and dust-spinners, Beka tracks the opals and the Shadow Snake. Crookshank killed 17 people to keep his opals secret. Beka befriends Rosto, Kora, and Aniki, new members of the Rogueās court from Scanra. She divides her time between the opals, and the Shadow Snake. Crookshank blames the Rogue for Rolandās death, and the kidnapping of his grandson.
Eventually, Beka discovers the location of Crookshankās mine, and the Dogs move in. They rescue the current work crew, dig up the dead crews, and arrest the guards. A riot starts the next day after the news of Crookshankās mine breaks. Rosto locates the Shadow Snake and Herum, Tansyās husband. They rescue Herum, and discover the Shadow Snake was Yates Noll, and his mother, āthe kindlyā baker. The book ends when Rosts becomes the new Rogue.
Past and Itās Benefits
Present and Past with Pounce and Poverty
One of Pierceās successes is how she links the present and the past together. She does this several ways, through character links, and through class links. The most obvious character link is Pounce. Pierce draws on the emotions regarding the cat and constellation that followed Alanna fromĀ In the Hand of the GoddessĀ on. Pounce also follows Beka, and we see how this spirit cat became who he was for Alanna. She uses him to tie us to Beka and her story. Pounce also grows in this story, being somewhat cattier than inĀ Song of the Lioness. āPounce trotted past the newcomers, carrying a black kitten ā¦Ā I cannot let you maul me about. Do it to him.ā (427). In doing so, we see how his patience grows from past to present.
Pierce also uses her ties to the past significantly. She opens the book with Eleni bailing out a young George. Eleni tells him about, āRebakah Cooper ⦠She was a fierce and law-abiding and loyal, my son. All that I want for you. ⦠Steal and you shame her.ā (6). Afterwards, Eleni asks the Goddess to guide him on Bekaās path, instead of the theiving path he eventually takes. By utilizing irony here, as well as at the end, when Rosto plans to build the Dancing Dove, we see how the universe connects past and present.
Also in Eleniās prologue is the revelation George started stealing because she couldnāt afford to feed them enough. This ties into the other theme that ties present and past together, that of poverty. Beka is the first POV from the lower class since Daine, and Daine talked mostly to the nobility. She counts coppers, and worries about rent. Even though the Provost fostered her, she remains part of the lower classes, which provides valuable insight.
Womenās Rights ā Knights, Priestesses, and Pedestals
Lady Knight Sabine of Macayhill proves one of the most influential secondary characters in all ofĀ Terrier. She is the first lady knight that we meet that never once is treated differently because of her gender. Alanna struggles with acceptance of her gender. Kel succeeds only despite prejudice against female knights. With Sabine, we see the age that inspires them, where lady knights were never doubted, never disparaged for their skills.Ā Sabine rescues Beka from a tavern brawl that would have killed any other Puppy. She helps Tunstall, Clary, and Beka track down Crookshankās mine and harry Duwall, one of the Rogueās chiefs. Her fellow knights and nobles respect her. Itās immensely refreshing.
We also see respect for womenās rights in the religious arena. Fulk often sexually harasses women. When Bekaās Dogs ask him to identify the fire opal, he harasses Beka. They stop him. Clary threatens to send him before the Goddessās temple. Tunstall clarifies. āAt the last eclipse, the Mother of Starlight temple chose Magistrates. Goodwinās now the Goddessās Magistrate ⦠She signs a writ, and the warrior [ladies] with the sickles come for him.ā (86). While violence against women remains a problem for Tortall, past and present, itās a step in the right direction. It shows the slow steps of progress.
Finally, in a more meta-textual level, women now have the right to be villains. Thereās equality between evil women and evil men for the first time in Pierceās novels. Roger, Ozorne, Blayce, Rubinyan, all male. Now, the Shadow Snake is the primary antagonist, and sheās Mistress Noll. Yes, weāve had female secondary antagonists, Imajane, and Delia come to mind. But if you put women on pedestals and donāt let them be flawed, then youāve only entered another phase of misogyny. Pierce takes steps to correct this here.
The Past and Itās Problems
Slavery
The thing that shocked me most inĀ Terrier was the depiction of slavery. After the very successfulĀ Tricksterās Duology, to include slavery and to not even mention freeing slaves dissapointed me. In addition, this is the first we hear of any slavery being in Tortallās past. While the importance of not whitewashing history is clear to me, Pierce simply could have not included slavery inĀ Terrier and in Tortallās past.Ā Not only is it slavery, it is child slavery, and state sponsered slavery, and a complete reversal of the slave positions of Scanra and Tortall.
Child slavery proves a significant problem, when Beka investigates the Shadow Snake. She uncovers people who sold their children and claimed the Snake took them, or children genuinely taken for the slave trade. āSlave taking is disliked in Corus, but it isnāt illegal. Kidnapping children without their parentsā leave is illegal though.ā (79). To clarify, parents can sell their children into slavery, but other people cannot. It is morally disgusting, and Beka prostests it only minimally.
We know the Crown sponsers slavery because not only is there a, āMinistry of Slave Salesā (384), but illegal slave markets get broken up by Beka and the Guard several times. The āillegal slaversā set up a stable to ālook like a proper slave market.ā (384). After seeing Aly destroy the slave markets in Rajmuat, after seeing a rebellion that freed slaves, this grows intolerable. Scanra also doesnāt have many slaves since they canāt feed free citizens, let alone enslaved ones. Given that slaves work most of the farms in Scanra in the present, it feels Pierce merely flipped Scanraās present with Tortallās past to make the past darker. That doesnāt sit well with me. It shows insensitivity on issues she handled well previously.
Diversity and the Watsonian Lens
On a Doylist level, the amount of diversity inĀ Terrier showās Pierceās advancing commitment to intersectional feminism. Take Sergeant Ahuda, the chief of the Guard Post where Beka trains, for example. āShe is a stocky black woman with some freckle and hair she has straightened and cut just below her ears. Her family is in Carthak, far in the south. They say she treats trainees the way she does in vengeance for how the Carthakis treated her family as slaves.ā (25). While the last sentance is dubious, she still remains a POC woman in charge of several dozen people. Thatās wonderful, and Pierce develops her more than she did Sarge, inĀ The Immortals Quartet.
In addition, Pierce shows people of color moving around Corus.Ā ā[The Rogue]ād foreigners with him, two Yamanis with their hair in topknots. With them stood the Carthaki whoād had Kayferās ear my first knight at the Court.ā (399) Bazhir also move around the streets, though in a slightly more insular fashion. This reflects their isolation inĀ Woman Who Rides Like A Man. This amazes from a Doylist sense, that Pierce moved so far from that contentious book.
But, in a Watsonian lens of thinking about books, it proves problematic. The diversity here only highlights the lack of diversity in her first series.Ā Song of the Lioness doesnāt even mention non-white characters until the third book, and I find that depiction contentious. Something had to change between Tortallās past and the present we see here that changed Tortallās opinion of people of color. We know it results from the chronological evolution of Pierceās feminism, but still. It also makes you wonder what happened that Lady Knights no longer were accepted. It may be this question is answered in the next too books. But still.
Police Novels and Modern Feminism
I donāt believe it especially controversial to mention that for the last decade or so, weāve started having conversations about police brutality and corruption. It spawned movements, endless articles, and websites devoted to tracking cases of brutality and corruption. So, this makes it hard to see feminism and feminist movements in Police and Crime novels likeĀ Terrier. From our perspective now, we see a novel such asĀ Terrier that contains moments of āpoliceā corruption and brutality, and find it difficult to endorse.Ā But that doesnāt mean itās not worth looking at.
Thankfully, no police brutality against unarmed and disenfranchised victims occurs inĀ Terrier to my judgement. I might miss something, but the closest thing to brutality I saw lies in the ānap tapā. āAll of us love that hammer blow of baton against jaw, even if it doesnāt always knock a Rat out. Goodwin has the cityās record for the highest number of perfectly delivered nap taps that end with a Rat carried away, stone unconscious.ā (192). Beka hesitates at one point about hitting a tavern brawler that is attacking her with her baton, fearful that sheāll seriously hurt him. They do use riot gear at one point, when a riot forms when the news of Crookshankās mines gets out. But those two moments are the closest the Provostās Dogs inĀ Terrier come to modern worries of police brutality.
Police Corruption
Unfortunately, corruption proves differently. Someone kills a Dog that gambled with weighted dice, and Beka sympathizes with him. āOf course there are crooked Dogs. I can name two handfuls myself. ⦠I do not like that he was crooked. But heād still been a Dog.ā (201). The insular community of the Dogs allows some exceptions for bad behavior if the perpetrator was a Dog.
Corruption also comes in the Happy Bags. āOther Dogs collect Happy Bags from each business that wants to know otherwise ill-paid Dogs will watch over them with diligence.ā (92). In addition they collect from the Rogue which buys some peace between his Court and the Dogs. āNot taking offense over a bit of briber, are you? ⦠On the very night your Dogs are here to collect their bribes from the Rogue. ⦠Thatās different. Thatās for all the work every one of us does, to keep the streets orderly.ā (107).Ā But itās not just for keeping the streets orderly. Dogs get personal bribes as well as the institution of the Happy Bag. And their bribe from the Rogue is not only in repayment for public order, but also keeps the Dogs away from several places. Places where the Rogue hides stolen goods, and where Yates hides from the Dogs.
The Dogs get funding almost entirely from the Happy Bags. Beka does not have a single qualm about the bribes that fund her work. She simply accepts it, and in some way the reader accepts it as well. Or they would if the conversation over police didnāt become so strident in recent years.
The mostly non-existent brutality and the blatant corruption make it difficult to read feminism in this book. After all, intersectional feminist groups spent years discussing and protesting this kind of behavior.
Conclusion
Overall, I believe thatĀ TerrierĀ continues Pierceās trend of increasing feminism. The way she includes diversity, even though it creates a Watsonian problem, convinces me of that. The depiction of slavery remains problematic, but I believe that her overall attempts at feminism trump that. Itās also balanced by the central nature ofĀ slavery in theĀ Tricksterās Duology.Ā However, the depiction of police corruption makes this book a harder sell to the modern liberal audience than when Pierce first published it.
Hopefully, Pierceās expanding feminism continues as we enter the books that I have not yet read or reviewed.